When reading over the "banned books" list, I was shocked to discover that The Complete Persepolis was on the list. I read over the allegations made against the book, "Reasons: gambling, offensive language, political viewpoint. Additional reasons: 'politically, racially, and socially offensive,' 'graphic depictions.'" I was in shock. I immediately recollected my memories of the book. I asked myself, "What could possibly be inappropriate?" The only minor reason that this book could be deemed inappropriate was the minor drug use that Marjane participated in. However, "drug use" does not appear on the list of reasons deeming this book inappropriate (which makes no sense as the other reasons are irrelevant to the book.)
Seeing this book on the list reminds me of how important it is to explore controversial topics as adolescents. For example, if a teenager is sheltered and is not exposed to mature topics of the world, how will this individual fare in the real world? Will this individual be appalled at the sex, drugs, and crimes of the world or will this individual embrace the changes? Seeing this book on the list also reminds me of how grateful I am to attend a school which celebrates more controversial topics. I also appreciate how open the teachers are to exploring these topics without judging their students. When discussing typically uncomfortable topics in class, I feel comfortable because I have faith in the open-mindedness of the students and teachers. Reading controversial works reminds me of the lengths I would go to if my freedom of reading was limited. If reading banned literature resulted in serious consequences, I would still read. I believe that knowledge is power. When I read controversial works, I feel more knowledgeable because I am exposed to new topics that I would not typically discuss in everyday life. Ultimately, I think it is imperative to explore uncomfortable topics because it leads to individual growth.
I totally agree with your point on how young adults should be exposed to these kind of issues instead of avoiding them. Since they will be encountering the mature topics in the future anyways, it is better to learn to accept the reality at an early age.
ReplyDeleteHi Meghan!
ReplyDeleteYour point about the importance of exploring these controversial topics is something that I totally agree with, and is important in the settings you described. As we move into Balzac and the Little Chinese Seamstress, the sheltered nature of such topics is something I find myself thinking about. Especially since China has had such a sheltered experience in our current global existence since dynasties were still in power. It is interesting to ponder how the world would be different if people accepted some of the ideas you mention here. Who knows, if we were more accepting of controversial political viewpoints, relations with other countries may have progressed very differently, and maybe even more successfully.
Thank you for providing such an interesting idea!
-Jake
Meghan, I agree with you that the students and teacher here at Sage are very open-minded and create a comforable environment for discussing these sort of topics. I found it interesting how you wrote that exploring these topics leads to individual growth. I think that it is very true because they are the source of new knowledge, and as you wrote "knowledge is power."
ReplyDelete